The ""jurisdictional fact doctrine"" in New South Wales local government and environmental planning law
- Thomson Lawbook Company
- Publication Type:
- Journal article
- Ellis-Jones Ian 2006, 'The "jurisdictional fact doctrine" in New South Wales local government and environmental planning law', Thomson Lawbook Co., vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 16-35.
- Issue Date:
Errors made with respect to jurisdictional matters, including errors made with respect to so-called 'Jurisdictional facts", are reviewable for 'Jurisdictional error". A jurisdictional fact is some fact or fact situation which must exist in fact as a condition precedent or essential prerequisite for the primary decision-maker to exercise its jurisdiction. Over the past 15 years New South Wales superior courts have increasingly applied the so-called 'Jurisdictional fact doctrine" in local government and environmental planning law cases. This article discusses a number of important judicial authorities and seeks to identify what the key elements or indicators of the presence of a jurisdictional fact situation in a particular statutory formulation are. They include: the interrelated elements of "objectivity" and "essentiality"; the purpose of the formulation in the overall legislative scheme; the inconvenience, if any, that may arise from the fact situation being held to be jurisdictional; whether the fact situation occurs or arises as a matter for consideration or as a matter to be ultimately adjudicated upon by the tribunal of fact; whether the fact situation occurs or arises in the actual formulation of the grant of substantive power to the tribunal of fact to make the ultimate decision on the merits; and whether the fact situation occurs or arises in a formulation requiring the formation by the tribunal of fact of a specified mental state. Ultimately, it is an issue of statutory construction and legislative intention, with the reviewing court having the final say, at least on those matters.
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: