Prior distributions for random choice structures

Publication Type:
Journal Article
Citation:
Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 2013, 57 (3-4), pp. 78 - 93
Issue Date:
2013-01-01
Metrics:
Full metadata record
Files in This Item:
Filename Description Size
Thumbnail2013001086OK.pdf883.78 kB
Adobe PDF
We study various axioms of discrete probabilistic choice, measuring how restrictive they are, both alone and in the presence of other axioms, given a specific class of prior distributions over a complete collection of finite choice probabilities. We do this by using Monte Carlo simulation to compute, for a range of prior distributions, probabilities that various simple and compound axioms hold. For example, the probability of the triangle inequality is usually many orders of magnitude higher than the probability of random utility. While neither the triangle inequality nor weak stochastic transitivity imply the other, the conditional probability that one holds given the other holds is greater than the marginal probability, for all priors in the class we consider. The reciprocal of the prior probability that an axiom holds is an upper bound on the Bayes factor in favor of a restricted model, in which the axiom holds, against an unrestricted model. The relatively high prior probability of the triangle inequality limits the degree of support that data from a single decision maker can provide in its favor. The much lower probability of random utility implies that the Bayes factor in favor of it can be much higher, for suitable data. © 2013 Elsevier Inc.
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: