Tyre profiling : development and evolution of forensic methodology

Publication Type:
Thesis
Issue Date:
2009
Full metadata record
Files in This Item:
Filename Description Size
Thumbnail01Front.pdf10.82 MB
Adobe PDF
Thumbnail02Whole.pdf109.46 MB
Adobe PDF
The chemical analysis of tyres is not a routine part of forensic investigation. The use of tyres as evidence has been limited to comparison of the tread pattern. However, the tread pattern is not the only evidence that may be left behind by a tyre. When a tyre skids across a hard road surface such as bitumen or concrete, residue from the tyre may be left behind. It was the aim of this research to develop a method for the analysis of tyres and their residues, understand the amount of chemical variation in tyres, identify suitable methods for the collection of tyre residues from different road surfaces, and to classify tyre samples and identify the source of tyre residues. A suitable method for analysis was successfully developed using pyrolysis-gas chromatography/mass spectrometry. It was found that pyrolysis was best completed at 450 °C using a furnace type pyrolyser. Chemical variation was investigated in a single tyre, in tyres over time, in production batches, and between different models and sizes of tyres from the same manufacturer. Small variations were found within a single tyre and in tyres over time. Greater variation was observed in both the same and different production batches, and between different model tyres and different size tyres. Three different collection techniques were investigated - picking, adhesive tape, and swabbing. Picking was found to be the most suitable technique to use on a concrete road with gravel aggregate, while a fingerprint lift was found to be the most suitable technique on a bitumen road surface. Swabbing was found to be an unsuitable technique. Six replicate analyses were used to catalogue changes in the chemical composition between the tyre and the residue. Numerous changes were observed such that only a limited number of signals from the chromatogram could be used for identification purposes. Three different techniques were used for classification and identification - relative polymer content (RPC), target compound identification (TCI), and linear discriminant analysis (LDA). LDA was found to be the most successful technique, correctly classifying 31 of 36 tyre residues. PyGCMS allows for simple analysis of tyre samples and residues without pre-treatment. A tyre sample was found to have 5-10% variation in the relative polymer content, regardless of when during the life of the tyre the sample was taken. Variation was found between tyres from the same manufacturer. Both similarities and differences were found between tyres from the same production batch and different production batches, suggesting that homogeneity in a single production batch not guaranteed and that manufacturers will also change the composition of a tyre between different production batches. The collection of tyre residues (like the collection of any forensic evidence) may or may not be successful depending specifically on the type of road surface. Collection of tyre residues from a concrete road with gravel aggregate was successfully achieved through picking. Collection of tyre residues from a bitumen road was successfully achieved; however adhesive contamination from both the fingerprint lift and clear adhesive tape interfered with the PyGCMS analysis. Tyre residues were successfully correlated to the source tyre, but the process of collecting sample information from numerous replicate analyses of both the tyre sample and residue for data analysis was a time-consuming one.
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: